Skip to content
← All posts

Gold EAs

MT4 vs MT5 for EAs: Differences That Matter When You Choose a Robot

EABuild Team · · 9 min read

MT4 vs MT5 for EAs: Differences That Matter When You Choose a Robot – EABuild

If you are comparing MT4 vs MT5 for EAs, the choice matters more than it first seems, because an expert advisor (a program that places and manages trades for you inside MetaTrader) is built for one platform and will not run on the other. This post explains the differences that affect an EA user: file types, the strategy tester, account types, order handling and the programming language behind each platform. It gives no verdict on which platform is better, because that depends on your broker and the EA you want to run.

What is being compared, and by which criteria

MetaTrader 4 (MT4) and MetaTrader 5 (MT5) are both trading platforms from MetaQuotes. MT4 is the older one and MT5 is its successor, but MT5 did not replace MT4 in practice. Many brokers still offer both, and many EAs exist for only one of them.

The criteria below are the ones that change what you do when you pick, install and test an EA:

  • File types: which compiled file the platform accepts.
  • Strategy tester: how you check an EA's behaviour on historical data before trading live.
  • Account type: whether you can hold buy and sell positions on the same symbol at once.
  • Order handling and timeframes: what the platform lets an EA do on a chart.
  • Language and ecosystem: why an EA cannot simply be moved across.

Most traders get the terminal from their broker, so that the server list is already set up.

File types: EX4 and EX5

An EA you download is usually a compiled file. Compiled means the human-readable code has been translated into a form MetaTrader can run but a person cannot easily read. MT4 uses the EX4 extension for compiled programs, and MT5 uses EX5.

The editable source files follow the same split: MQ4 for MT4 and MQ5 for MT5. In short, source is the text a person edits and compiled is the runnable result.

The practical consequence is simple. An EX4 file placed in MT5 will not load, and an EX5 file placed in MT4 will not load. Renaming the extension does nothing. If a product is listed for MT4, you need an MT4 terminal; if it is listed for MT5, you need an MT5 terminal.

The folders differ in the same way. Both platforms keep a data folder with an Experts subfolder for EAs, but each terminal has its own data folder. Our step-by-step guides cover the details: how to install an EA in MT4 and how to install an EA in MT5.

The strategy tester

The strategy tester is the built-in tool that runs an EA on historical price data so you can watch how it would have behaved. It is useful for checking that an EA loads, opens and closes orders as you expect, and responds to its settings. It does not predict future results, and a test on past data says nothing certain about live trading.

MT4 tester

The MT4 tester runs one test at a time on a single symbol. It offers several modelling modes, from one that uses only opening prices of each bar to one that simulates every tick. Tick data in MT4 is generated from minute bars, so it is an approximation of how price moved inside each minute.

MT5 tester

The MT5 tester can run on real tick history supplied by your broker as well as on generated ticks. It can test an EA that trades several symbols, and it can spread an optimisation (a run of many tests with different input values) across several processor cores or networked agents. It also includes a visual mode that replays a test on a chart.

What this means for you

If the EA you want trades one symbol on one timeframe, either tester can show you how it loads and behaves. If you plan to run many optimisation passes or want to test with broker tick data, MT5 gives you more tools. In both cases, the results depend on the quality of the history data, so treat any test as a check of mechanics, not as a forecast. Test on a demo account first and check the settings before you trade live.

Hedging and netting accounts

This is the difference that most often decides whether an EA behaves as described. A hedging account lets you hold a buy position and a sell position on the same symbol at the same time. A netting account keeps one combined position per symbol: a new order in the opposite direction reduces or closes the existing position instead of opening a second one.

MT4 is built around the hedging model, so separate positions on one symbol are normal, although your broker can still restrict hedging on its servers. MT5 started with netting only and later added the hedging account type. Which one you get is a broker setting chosen when the account is opened, not a choice you make in the terminal.

An EA written around opening many separate positions on one symbol, such as a grid strategy (one that opens extra orders at set price steps) or one that opens opposite positions together, expects a hedging account. On a netting account the same EA may behave differently, because its orders merge into one position. Always check the account type with your broker and read what the EA listing says about hedging before you run it.

Order handling, timeframes and language

MT5 offers more than MT4 in several areas. It has 21 timeframes against nine in MT4, and it adds more pending order types, including stop-limit orders. It also has a built-in economic calendar and market depth view for symbols where the broker supplies them. None of these makes an EA better by itself; they only matter if the EA is written to use them.

The platforms use different programming languages. MT4 programs are written in MQL4 and MT5 programs in MQL5, which is closer to C++ and supports object-oriented code. They are related but not interchangeable, so moving an EA from one platform to the other means rewriting and recompiling it, not copying it. This is why an EA's two versions often have different version numbers, settings and sometimes different strategy descriptions. You can read the language reference on the MQL5 documentation site.

It also means a favourite EA on one platform may have no counterpart on the other. Do not assume an MT5 version exists because an MT4 one does.

Side by side

TopicMT4MT5
Compiled EA fileEX4EX5
Source fileMQ4MQ5
LanguageMQL4MQL5
Account modelHedging, subject to broker rulesNetting or hedging, set by the broker
TesterOne symbol per test, generated ticksMulti-symbol tests, real tick history where available, multi-core optimisation
Timeframes921
Pending ordersLimit and stopLimit, stop and stop-limit

Examples from the shop: one name, two platforms

Shop listings show how platform choice appears in practice. These examples describe each product by its listing facts only; they are not a ranking.

The same gold EA name on MT4 and MT5

Happy Gold EA for MT4 is an expert advisor for MetaTrader 4 listed for XAUUSD on M15 and M30. The listing states grid, martingale and hedging logic, version 2.0, with a minimum build of 1471. Martingale means the lot size grows after a losing trade, so drawdown (the drop from an account's peak balance) can rise quickly.

Happy Gold EA for MT5 is listed for XAUUSD on the same two timeframes, with hedging and scalping logic, version 2.1, and the download holds two compiled files. The two share a name but not a version number or a strategy line. Read each listing on its own.

An MT4 scalper and an MT5 grid EA

Gold Scalping EA for MT4 is a scalping and breakout EA listed for XAUUSD on M5 and M15. It includes two compiled files and one set file, which is a saved list of input settings you load in the EA's inputs window.

Mad Turtle EA for MT5 is listed for XAUUSD on H1 and M15 with scalping, grid and martingale logic, and the download includes one compiled file and seven set files. Because it uses a grid, the account type matters: confirm with your broker how positions on one symbol are handled before you run it. Each set file is a starting configuration, not a recommendation of results.

Which reader each platform fits

MT4 may fit if

  • the EA you want is listed only for MT4;
  • your broker offers MT4 with hedging allowed;
  • you want a simpler terminal with fewer features to learn.

MT5 may fit if

  • the EA you want is listed only for MT5;
  • you want the more detailed tester or more timeframes;
  • your broker offers an MT5 account type that suits the EA's order handling.

A short checklist before you decide

  1. Pick the EA first and read which platform and minimum build it lists.
  2. Ask your broker which platforms it offers and, on MT5, whether the account is netting or hedging.
  3. Check the symbol name your broker uses, since some add a suffix to XAUUSD.
  4. Install the file in the matching terminal and load any set file from the inputs window.
  5. Run it on a demo account and watch how it handles orders before you trade live.

If the EA is built for gold, the gold EA guide explains how XAUUSD EAs work and what to check before you buy.

Where to go next

You can browse the expert advisors in the shop; each listing names its platform. Every product is also included in the membership, which gives you access to the whole catalogue as digital downloads.

Trading foreign exchange and CFDs carries a high level of risk and may not be suitable for all investors. Past performance does not guarantee future results; only trade with money you can afford to lose.

Tags: MT4 vs MT5, Expert Advisors, Strategy Testing

← All posts

Get every EA with membership

313 products · from $16.59/month

See plans

More in Gold EAs